What is Paula on tonight????

I thought she might be reading from notes they made during rehersal or something and just forgot where she was ~lol!!  What an embarrassment ~ what are they going to do with Ms. Babble anyway???

Very Juice Newton ~ yuck!

Paula can't spit it out...good grief!  Strangest show???   No Paula just can't hide her "craziness" tonight

I think that Brooke should go, also. She forgot her words or messed up during her performances twice before and her version of "I'm a Believer" was a total nightmare. Jason has been really good before. He better bring up his game if he doesnt want to get out. And Paula... I've always wondered if the judges had things already pre-ready (On notes?) to say. Maybe not but now I'm suspicious. 

  Here's my recap of the show this week:

Jason Castro:  "Forever In Blue Jeans":  decent performance...he doesn't have the strong timbre that Neil Diamond has when he sings this song;  "September Morn":  a so-so performance; a bit pitchy in spots; he showed no feelings in the song; Jason was slammed by all the judges.

David Cook:  "I'm Alive" and "All I Really Need Is You":  he did well in both songs, although his performances were really nothing special...at least he was in tune!

Brooke White:  "I'm A Believer":  blah...!  Her voice was too low for parts of this song and her words were not distinct; "I Am I Said":  this performance was much better...she did a good job with this song.

David Archuleta: (my sweet, wonderful, pretty boy) "Sweet Caroline":  was a very nice performance, although not his best; "America":  what can I say except OMG!  This was a great song choice for young David.  I will have to listen to his full-length performance on iTunes;  I was hoping before the show began that he would get to choose this song to sing, and he did.  David has such a great personality...his smile and his soft-spoken ways makes me melt!     Everyone just keep away from David...and nobody will get hurt! 

Syesha Mercado:  "Hello":  this was a nice, solid performance; "Thank The Lord For The Night Time":  not a bad performance.  The music of this song sounds eerily like "I'm A Believer"...a person could sing the words of I'm A Believer to this song.....

  Finally!  She got her butt canned! 

Oh, and for last night's Paula Incident...boy, she was acting crazier than a rabid skunk!  It was hilarious...her messing up the critique of the contestants.  Poor Paula...I still love her, though.  And it was all explained on the news too. 

Yeah, and such a coherent explaination too!  I like her, but there are times when I think they should just tell her to say "good job" ~ clap all crazy, and SIT DOWN! 


Yeah, but I don't have to watch that one!!  I can't miss the Davids singing!!  I think I am gonna download both of David Cook's songs!

LMAO..   

I think they have to have the votes that gets people's attention and makes them tune in to see what the heck is going on.  I can't help but to think that is why they booted Michael Johns!  When it didn't up the audience, then they got rid of Carley.  They wouldn't get rid of the Davids because that is going to be the final two ~ period!  Everyone is wanting to see that battle.  I think Syesha is the next to go, followed by Jason.  Then you have the two David's fighting it out.  I would love to see David Cook win, and maybe they will due to the fact that a rocker hasn't ever won, BUT they made sure to put out the bad press on Archie's Dad...makes me thing that he might be the one who wins.  Sorta root for the poor kid that is mentally abused and has overcome hardships to win it all type thing.

Don't get me wrong ~ I love Archie's voice, but I'm not sure that he should win...I think DC has showed more originality and can be a great over-all singer.  It should make for a interesting final! 

I haven't seen that interview, but from what I have heard that wouldn't surprise me...I hope he gets a great contract and gets away from him...even though my gut says that he won't ~ he is probably to beaten down!

Yeah, part of me wonders if Archie's timidity is due to mistreatment.  I hate saying that, because one never really knows another family's situation, but at the very least, it seems from the Judd interview and other things I've read that his dad is a bit of control freak in all areas of Archie's life.  Whether that's because he's the family star and Dad is living vicariously through son or it's simply a matter of a dad loving too much, who knows?

Personally, I'm having a hard time deciding between the two Davids.  Archuleta certainly has a better voice, but I think Cook brings something extra to his songs.  DC simply has more life experience and has dealt with more situations that he can use in his music.  It's a tough call.  They're both very good.

P.S. I don't like Jason or Syesha.  Syesha has some pitch issues, and Jason is... well, unique.

Well, I have to say that Archie was my favorite tonight!  I didn't like DC's first song that well, and the second one didn't blow me away either! 

I think unless something really strange happens that this was Jason's last performances!  Both of those were pretty bad!

Great minds think alike! 

I think both the David's will be big stars...I like them both!!

bye jason     Not a surprise at all. Its about time.

At least Jason took it with a smile.  Who do you think will win?