Wait, I think I might know what it is.
Five hundred (500) First Prizes: An Entenmann's Donut Man Plush Toy. ARV of each First Prize is $6.
Did you ever enter the Entenmann's Donut Day sweeps? It was a daily. Looks like the first prize was some kind of donut toy. lol Well, a win is a win! Congrats to you and me!